What Is Cloaking in Advertising?

What is cloaking in advertising? Showing an ad platform's crawlers and reviewers a compliant landing page while sending the people who click the ad to a different one.

What is cloaking in advertising: showing an ad platform’s crawlers and reviewers a compliant landing page while sending the people who click the ad somewhere else. The ad passes review. The visitor lands on what the advertiser wanted hidden.

What the platforms say

  • Google Ads: “showing different content on your website to different people or to Google to try to hide things that might break Google Ads’ rules”. Example given: showing sale of clothing to Google when the website sells guns (Google Ads policy).
  • Meta: presenting different off-platform content “to our integrity systems versus what is shown to users” (Meta spam standard).

Allowed under Google Ads: different languages, different special offers, changes for location or slow connections. The promoted product must be the same for everyone.

How it works

The landing page decides per request who is asking. Signals the cloaking services in a Google study used (Cloak of Visibility):

signal term
visitor IP, reverse DNS IP-based cloaking
user agent user-agent cloaking
referrer (did they click an ad) referrer cloaking
country geo cloaking
JavaScript support JavaScript cloaking

The reviewer-facing side has its own page: ad review cloaking.

How big is it

In that study (2016, 135,577 search and ad URLs tied to high-risk keywords), 4.9% of Google Ads URLs in health and software ads were cloaked, and 11.7% of top-100 Google Search results for luxury storefronts. The authors say they make no claim that Google fails to detect these URLs. [TODO: newer public figure]

How to spot it

  1. Load the landing page as a crawler and as an ad click, compare: website cloaking checker.
  2. Do it by hand: check a site with curl.
  3. Screening many advertisers: for ad networks.

Website cloaking · Redirect cloaking · How ad networks detect cloaking

Questions

What does cloaking mean?

Serving different content depending on who is looking. In advertising it means the reviewer or crawler gets a page that passes the rules and the real visitor gets another.

What is Google's cloaking policy for ads?

Google Ads bans cloaking under its circumventing systems policy: showing different content to different people or to Google to hide things that would break the ad rules. Language, offers and location changes are fine if the promoted product is the same for everyone.

How does cloaking work?

The landing page checks the visitor's IP, user agent, referrer, country or JavaScript support, and serves the clean page to anything that looks like a reviewer.

How to detect cloaking?

Load the landing page as a crawler and as an ad click, then compare. The free checker does it.