Ad Review Cloaking: How It Works

Ad review cloaking is when an advertiser's landing page shows the ad platform's review crawler or reviewer a compliant page and sends real ad clicks to a different one.

Ad review cloaking is when an advertiser’s landing page shows the ad platform’s review crawler or human reviewer a compliant page, and sends the people who click the ad to a different one. It is cloaking in advertising aimed at the review step.

Who the reviewer is

platform crawler user agent
Google Ads AdsBot (checks web page ad quality) AdsBot-Google (+http://www.google.com/adsbot.html), AdsBot-Google-Mobile (Google Ads help)
Meta link crawler (also used for security and integrity checks) facebookexternalhit/1.1 (+http://www.facebook.com/externalhit_uatext.php) (Meta crawlers)

Google lists AdsBot as a special-case crawler. Its requests come from IPs that resolve to rate-limited-proxy-*.google.com, listed in a published file (Google docs).

What the rules say

  • Google Ads example: “Showing Google a landing page or an ad’s destination that complies with Google Ads’ policies while showing people different content” (Google Ads policy).
  • Meta: different off-platform content “to our integrity systems versus what is shown to users” (Meta spam standard).

How to spot it

The signals are the usual ones: user agent, IP, referrer, country, JavaScript. Load the landing page as an ad crawler and as an ad click, compare: website cloaking checker. Screening at scale: for ad networks.

Redirect cloaking · How ad networks detect cloaking · Website cloaking

Questions

What does an ad platform's crawler look like?

Google's ad crawler sends AdsBot-Google or AdsBot-Google-Mobile as its user agent. Meta's link crawler sends facebookexternalhit/1.1, which Meta says may also do security and integrity checks.

What is the penalty?

Google Ads treats cloaking as circumventing systems; its policy page has a section on fixing a suspended account. Meta says it restricts or removes accounts that egregiously or persistently violate its policies ([Meta account integrity](https://transparency.meta.com/policies/ad-standards/business-assets/account-integrity)).